Letter to San Francisco Arts Commission Urges for Rehabilitation of Embarcadero and Vaillancourt Fountain

UPDATE: The article below this update was originally published on September 26, 2025. 

The future of the San Francisco Arts Commission's plans for the Vaillancourt Fountain are currently in limbo. The city is eager for the commission to deaccession the work from the Civic Art Collection, which would facilitate demolition. But recent news coverage, including a revelatory article in The Art Newspaper about responsibility for the fountain's maintenance, seem to have temporarily pushed the debate off the agenda. The article—City of San Francisco and developer appear to have planned Vaillancourt Fountain demolition before proposal was made public—said: "new information reveals that city officials had been discussing a planned redevelopment of the plaza around a decade before such plans were made public in 2024. Those plans did not appear to include preserving the landmark Vaillancourt Fountain—a public art asset the city of San Francisco has a legal responsibility to maintain—or the equally significant Embarcadero Plaza in which the monument is located."

The article also cited internal documents, including one from December 4, 1978, first published by The Cultural Landscape Foundation (TCLF) on August 25, 2025, revealing the "property developer leading [the] demolition effort [BXP, formerly Boston Properties] was at least partly responsible for fountain and plaza maintenance for nearly 50 years."

The article notes: "The findings are significant because they support the claims of those seeking to preserve Vaillancourt Fountain, namely that Rec officials have not been completely transparent as to their intent, nor their legal responsibility towards the sculptural fountain and Embarcadero Plaza. Rec officials argue the fountain and plaza are too dilapidated to be preserved, though they have not addressed why BXP—which according to documents reviewed by The Art Newspaper was responsible for at least some maintenance obligations for the past 45 years—let it deteriorate so severely."

Following an October 6 presentation by city officials to commission, advocates for the site expected the Visual Arts Committee to take up the deaccessioning question at their October 15 meeting. But it was not on the agenda. In addition, an October 22 Executive Committee Meeting is now listed as "cancelled." The matter could be discussed at the commission's next full meeting on November 3.  

TCLF strongly encourages concerned members of the public to write the San Francisco Arts Commission and urge them to reject the request by the RPD to deaccession the Vaillancourt Fountain and, instead, call for its rehabilitation. In addition, please cc Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Danny Sauter, whose district includes Embarcadero Plaza and the Vaillancourt Fountain. Contact information is at the bottom of this posting

TEXT OF THE ORIGINAL ARTICLE:

In an August 25, 2025 Landslide update, The Cultural Landscape Foundation (TCLF) reported that “the San Francisco Recreation and Parks Department (RPD) finally came out and admitted they want to demolish the   Fountain at the Lawrence Halprin-designed Embarcadero Plaza.” The fountain is owned by the San Francisco Arts Commission (SFAC) and is among artist Armand Vaillancourt’s most famous works. Unfortunately, it has been ill-maintained for years, its pumps no longer function, the basin around the fountain is dry, and the entire work is fenced off. In addition, newly-installed pickleball courts further barricade the site. 

To demolish the plaza and fountain, RPD must first get the SFAC to deaccession the work from the Civic Art Collection. The commission will next address the fountain’s future during their October 6 meeting. TCLF sent a letter (below, illustrated) to SFAC President Charles Collins and the other commissioners on September 25 urging the rehabilitation of the Vaillancourt Fountain and Embarcadero Plaza.

Charles Collins, President, and Commissioners 
San Francisco Arts Commission

Dear President Collins, and Commissioners: 

The Vaillancourt Fountain and Lawrence Halprin-designed Embarcadero Plaza are as unique to San Francisco as Coit Tower, the Ferry Building, and the Transamerica Pyramid Center. All these landmarks define San Francisco. However, unlike the latter three, the Vaillancourt Fountain and Embarcadero Plaza have not been well-maintained, and their diminished condition is being weaponized as justification for their demolition; and demolition is being presented as the only viable option.

Image

That’s ridiculous and commission members should not fall for this ruse. The Vaillancourt Fountain and Embarcadero Plaza can be rehabilitated to meet current needs and uses without destroying the very characteristics and artistry that make them unique. In fact, the City of Minneapolis provides an excellent roadmap for doing so.

Peavey Plaza (1974) in Minneapolis, a Modernist park/plaza designed by landscape architect M. Paul Friedberg with distinct and dramatic water features, like Vaillancourt, is in the heart of the city and due to deferred maintenance and lack of programming had fallen on hard times. The complex infrastructure issues that currently bedevil Vaillancourt were all present at Peavey. Initial plans called for demolishing the park; however, after years of hearings, advocacy at a national and local level, and a lawsuit, the city reversed course and rehabilitated Peavey Plaza. The result has been widely hailed, including by the same officials who actively campaigned for the site’s demolition (and who said there was no alternative to demolition), and recognized with numerous awards, including a major global honor recently from World Landscape Architecture and recent coverage in Metropolis magazine. Peavey Plaza is also operated and programmed by the city’s partner, the Minneapolis Downtown Development Improvement District. Indeed, the same type of stewardship relationship also exists with the Halprin Landscape Conservancy in Portland, Oregon, which serves as “stewards of the fountain district.”

Image

Another ruse the commission should not fall for concerns the budgets and estimates coming from the Recreation and Park Department (RPD). The 122-page report Vaillancourt Fountain Conditions Assessment prepared by RPD consultants Page & Turnbull includes an RPD memo that claims the fountain has “historically required extensive, near-daily maintenance” and that has “averaged approximately $100,000 per year, inclusive of documented labor costs, travel and equipment time, material handling, and additional support activities which reflect tens of thousands of cumulative labor hours.” RPD spokespeople were quoted for months in the media making the claim. 

The Cultural Landscape Foundation (TCLF), a Washington, D.C.-based education and advocacy non-profit established in 1998, FOIA’ed RPD for documents to support their claims. The response RPD sent to TCLF showed that:

1.    RPD had inflated the average annual budget by 250% 

2.    The “tens of thousands of cumulative labor hours” is actually 1,578.

Even if these numbers are “to be taken with a grain of salt,” as RPD’s Director of Operations Eric Andersen cautioned in a memo accompanying the estimates, they vastly exceed a rounding error.

This is the same RPD that said in June 2025 the cost to restore the Vaillancourt Fountain was $12 to $17 million and two months later said it’s actually $29 million (and portentously warns this would consume nearly all of the $30-35 million needed for a proposed new park).

Absent an audit by a neutral third party, the RPD’s restoration estimate should be treated with extreme skepticism.

In addition, the public forums run by RPD soliciting input about proposals for Embarcadero Plaza and the Vaillancourt Fountain only offered a tabula rasa approach and did not present the public with a rehabilitation option. Consequently, any representations by RPD about what the public wants are fundamentally flawed and woefully incomplete. The public’s choices have been deliberately limited.

TCLF has been advocating on behalf of Embarcadero Plaza and the Vaillancourt Fountain since 2016 when the site was included in a traveling photographic exhibition about Lawrence Halprin’s legacy organized by TCLF; the exhibition debuted at the National Building Museum in Washington, D.C., and was hosted at the Palace of Fine Arts in 2017. Sadly, since then the fountain and plaza’s condition has deteriorated because of insufficient maintenance. Nevertheless, while its condition is diminished, its integrity is very high. Indeed, TCLF continues to advocate for listing the plaza and fountain in the National Register of Historic Places.

Image

Even in its diminished physical condition, there is no other place in the world like Embarcadero Plaza and the Vaillancourt Fountain. None. 

They are immediately identifiable with the city and emblematic of its distinct and remarkable spirit. The publicly available renderings of the proposed replacement are trite, generic, and lacking in imagination—a kit of parts devoid of artistic value and civic gravitas, and unworthy of the City of San Francisco. 

On behalf of TCLF, I respectfully urge the Commissioners not to fall prey to the false choices and suspect data being provided by RPD and to the misguided notion that demolition is a fait accompli. 

Please heed the example of the City of Minneapolis and work with stakeholders to support a rehabilitation of this nationally significant work of art. TCLF stands ready to help.

Sincerely,  
Charles A. Birnbaum

What you can do to help

Write the San Francisco Arts Commission and urge them to reject the request by the RPD to deaccession the Vaillancourt Fountain and, instead, call for its rehabilitation. In addition, please cc Mayor Daniel Lurie and Supervisor Danny Sauter, whose district includes Embarcadero Plaza and the Vaillancourt Fountain (NOTE: TCLF is continuing to file records requests).

Chuck Collins, President
San Francisco Arts Commission
401 Van Ness Ave., #325
San Francisco, CA 94102
T: 415-252-2266
E: charles.collins1@sfgov.org  

Ralph Remington, Director of Cultural Affairs
San Francisco Arts Commission
401 Van Ness Ave., #325
San Francisco, CA 94102
T: 415-252-2266
E: art-info@sfgov.org  

Mayor Daniel Lurie
1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place
City Hall, Room 200
San Francisco, CA 94102-4689
T: (415) 554-6153
E: daniel.lurie@sfgov.org

Supervisor Danny Sauter 
1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place
City Hall, Room 244 
San Francisco, CA 94102-4689
T: (415) 554-7450
E: SauterStaff@sfgov.org